Week 4 review: best calls, bad beats and the trends that moved
Week 4 is in the books. Our trend picks went 44-30.
Best calls
- Northern Illinois at Georgia State: Georgia State -10.2 (following the model) 🔥. Final: Northern Illinois 14, Georgia State 35. Backed by Spread moved slightly the model's way (16-10).
- Northern Illinois at Georgia State: Under 56.5 (following the model) 🔥. Final: Northern Illinois 14, Georgia State 35. Backed by Same QBs as last game (24-14).
- Houston at Georgia Southern: Georgia Southern +17.2 (following the model) 🔥. Final: Houston 42, Georgia Southern 28. Backed by Spread moved slightly the model's way (16-10).
- Army at Temple: Army -3.5 (fading the model) 🔥. Final: Army 21, Temple 17. Backed by Total moved slightly against the model (24-13).
- Sam Houston at Texas Tech: Texas Tech -34.5 (fading the model) 🔥. Final: Sam Houston 14, Texas Tech 49. Backed by Model 10+ pts higher on the visitor (16-9).
Bad beats
- Mercyhurst at Western Kentucky: Under 58.8 (following the model) missed by 0.2. Final: Mercyhurst 7, Western Kentucky 52.
- UConn at Miami (OH): UConn +2.5 (following the model) missed by 0.5. Final: UConn 21, Miami (OH) 24.
- Iowa at Michigan: Over 39.8 (following the model) missed by 0.8. Final: Iowa 20, Michigan 19.
- Arizona at Washington State: Arizona -10.8 (fading the model) missed by 0.8. Final: Arizona 34, Washington State 24.
- Middle Tennessee at Jacksonville State: Middle Tennessee +7.0 (fading the model) missed by 3. Final: Middle Tennessee 13, Jacksonville State 23.
Trends that hit, and trends that missed
- ✅ Slight offensive edge (total): 12-2 this week
- ✅ Model within a point of the spread (total): 6-1 this week
- ✅ Afternoon kickoff (spread): 9-6 this week
- ❌ Road team favored (total): 3-6 this week
- ❌ Spread moved slightly the model's way (spread): 2-4 this week
- ❌ Fast-paced game (total): 1-3 this week
Trends on the move
- New follow: Regional road trip (total), now 36-22.
- New fade: Under-3 pt spread (spread), now 14-7.
- New fade: Model 3-6 pts higher on the home team (total), now 15-8.
- New follow: Model within a point of the spread (total), now 16-9.
- Dropped out: Unranked vs unranked (total) cooled off and no longer qualifies.
- Dropped out: An inexperienced QB (2-4 starts) (total) cooled off and no longer qualifies.
- Dropped out: Teams with 2-3 games played (total) cooled off and no longer qualifies.
What we're working on
- UCLA at Maryland: the model had Maryland by 5.4; UCLA won by 51. The biggest input was offensive efficiency edge.
- Gardner-Webb at Marshall: the model had Marshall by 35.7; Marshall won by 1. The biggest input was offensive efficiency edge.
- UNLV at Akron: the model had Akron by 2.3; UNLV won by 28. The biggest input was defensive efficiency edge.
- Early-season calibration: the model has run low on the home margin in weeks 1-2, and we are testing whether its early-season adjustment is sized right.
- Line movement: how far a line moves between open and close is now a tracked situation, and we are watching whether it earns a place in the trends.
The Thursday preview has this week's hot games. See this week's picks.
Trends describe what has happened; they are not guarantees. Not betting advice.