Where Jonathan Taylor fits best: ranking the five teams that should trade for him
The NFL trade deadline arrives Tuesday at 4pm ET, and the biggest name left on the board is Jonathan Taylor. The Colts have already dealt Quenton Nelson and DeForest Buckner, and they are open to moving their star running back for the right price. Five teams have checked in. The price is the problem. Here is our ranking.

The price, and what the market has already said
The Colts want a Christian McCaffrey package: a 2nd, a 3rd, a 4th, and a future 5th, the haul Carolina got from San Francisco in 2022. They have also held out for a 2027 1st, a pick they do not own after sending it to the Jets for Sauce Gardner. The Giants offered a 2nd and a 5th and walked away on Nov 8. Tom Pelissero reported Nov 7 that no team has come close to the ask, and that Taylor is increasingly likely to stay in Indianapolis.
The contract is the other half of the price. Taylor signed a two-year, $44 million extension in August, with $39 million in assured money. His cap hits are $16 million this season, $21 million in 2027, and $23 million in 2028, and his $15 million base salary for 2027 locks in February. A team trading for him now owes about $4 million for the rest of this season. Taylor has not asked for a trade.
Taylor is 27, a three-time Pro Bowler with four 1,000-yard seasons. Through Week 9 he has 161 carries for 656 yards and 8 rushing touchdowns on a team that is selling. The realistic price is a 2nd plus change, not a 1st and not the McCaffrey package: Taylor is older than McCaffrey was, and his deal is richer.
Why Indy can deal him: Seth McGowan is already the next man up
Rookie Seth McGowan, a 7th-round pick at 237th overall, beat out DJ Giddens for the RB2 job. He has 43 carries for 208 yards, nearly 5 yards per carry, and scored his first career touchdown from 2 yards out in Week 9. His share of the backfield has climbed from 17% to 23% over the last three weeks, while Taylor's has fallen from 67% to 54%. Steichen has said openly that the Colts are rotating McGowan in with Taylor, and the rookie has handled the late-game work in blowouts.
The goal-line work has still mostly been Taylor's, 86% of the running backs' red-zone chances against 14% for McGowan, but 10 of McGowan's first 37 carries moved the chains. If Taylor is dealt, McGowan starts immediately, and he does it on a rookie deal while Taylor's contract climbs toward $21 million and $23 million in cap hits. The replacement is already in the building.
The ranking

1. Minnesota Vikings (6-1)

The Vikings are the best fit, and it is not close on need. They are 6-1 behind the best defense in the league, and their run game ranks 27th in rushing EPA per play. Aaron Jones is 31 and has played through a sprained MCL since Week 2, averaging about 4 yards per carry, as is Jordan Mason after missing time with a fractured thumb. Taylor is an instant upgrade for this offense. The hurdle is money: Minnesota has about $6.5 million in cap space, so a deal likely needs salary going back to Indianapolis. Fit score: 9.
2. Denver Broncos (7-2)

Denver is a close second, and the only team in the mix that owns every pick the Colts want: a 2027 2nd, 3rd, 5th, and two 4ths. The Broncos have won five straight behind a top-four defense. RJ Harvey is on injured reserve with a knee injury, J.K. Dobbins is averaging about 3.5 yards per carry, and rookie Jonah Coleman has emerged as the top option. Taylor would be the workhorse Sean Payton has never had in Denver. The hurdle is the same as Minnesota's: about $4.5 million in cap space. Fit score: 8.
3. Seattle Seahawks (5-4)

Seattle is the stealth fit. The defending champions already did business with Indianapolis at this deadline, sending a 2027 3rd and a 2028 5th for Quenton Nelson. They balked at paying Kenneth Walker after the Super Bowl win, and Taylor's deal is richer than Walker's would have been. But the Seahawks are 5-4, and one national report called a Taylor deal the perfect deadline move. The two front offices have already agreed on a price once this month. Fit score: 7.
4. Green Bay Packers (6-3)

Green Bay is the block-Minnesota play. The Packers are 6-3, and their run game has been unsettled all year. Josh Jacobs missed the first six weeks and only returned in Week 7, and MarShawn Lloyd, who led the team in rushing while he was out, is now out with a knee injury. Taylor upgrades the room, and he keeps the best running back available out of the Vikings' backfield. Fit score: 6.
5. Cincinnati Bengals (6-2)

Cincinnati is the luxury swing. The Bengals are 6-2 and have won four straight, and Chase Brown is healthy and the lead back, handling 79% of the running back touches in Week 7. But Brown is averaging 3.5 yards per carry with 1 touchdown, and Samaje Perine has vultured goal-line work. Taylor would raise the ceiling of an offense that is already winning. Fit score: 5.
The verdict
The most likely outcome is still the one Pelissero called: Taylor stays, because the Colts' ask prices out every buyer. But if one team blinks before Tuesday at 4pm ET, the call is Minnesota, with Denver a close second. The price that gets it done is a 2nd plus change, not a 1st and not the McCaffrey package.
21+. If gambling stops being fun, call or text 1-800-GAMBLER.